Some advice on antennas for ADS-B reception
Best guess of what to try to fix first on your antenna.
In my antenna tests, I can't see a clear horizon in any direction. The antenna is also positioned in an eastward facing window which is relatively close to a number of trees and other structures.
Flight patterns also vary considerably day to day due to weather conditions. This makes repeatibilty over a number of hours necessary. Days or weeks would be better if you can wait that long.
Lots of experimenting (some futile and less repeatable) has gone into these. I currently recommend my 2nd version of the collinear coaxial antenna.
The dipole is effective and easy to build while the DVB-T antenna not tuned for 1090MHz was cannibalized before I could give it a proper test.
This is a very good off the shelf antenna and was a good sanity check for my existing antennae. It was also a good reminder that even a few cm of placment can get a very different result.
The FA antenna receives signals about 6NM further away than the CoCo. The exception to this is that arrivals to Houston along J87 show up 10-20NM before on the CoCo. The few cm difference in antenna could give a different reception corridor.
|Attribute:||FlightAware||4 element CoCo|
|Average planes tracked||31||29|
|Average with positions||18||17|
This is the coolest antenna I've seen so far which is a badge for the aerospace village @ defcon 28.
It's a basic dipole antenna but printed on a PCB shaped like a 787! The engine nacelles are SMA female ports and the 2nd one can be given custom wires for ACARS @ 131.550 MHz. It has nav and strobe lights which are programmable!
In spite of the good looks, it has an average range. When I installed in place of the 8 element CoCo, there was a sudden drop in distance. Later in the day I placed it higher in the window and got a little bit more range.
If you're going to be spotting in public, you can't pick a more stylish antenna than this.
Mostly the same antenna as my first design, this time adding 9th λ/4 coaxial segment with a longer λ/4 exposed wire. This is shorted to the sleeve of the 9th segment. The feed line has a Ferrite bead added λ/2 from the first segment.
I built this Coaxial Collinear Antenna since the Slovakian example seems to work so excellently. At first, I didn't think it was working correctly. The connection to the SDR was through a cut wire and alligator clips and dump1090 was running with --gain -10. Once I changed the feed line to a reasonable length of coax and attached it to a type-F to MCX connector things greatly improved.
This one is 10 segments of λ/2 coax jammed together with a longer feed line held inside a 48" sprinkler tube.
Being more than a meter long, this one is a bit of a challenge to use indoors and I doubt my neighbours would like me mounting this on top of the roof.
Forcing the coaxial segments together is also quite a bit more work than you would suspect from the videos.
Westward looking indoor collinar coaxial antenna recorded for 18 hours with --gain 46, you can see the edge of the window frame at 345°.
Maximum distance recorded was 207 km.
Eastward looking indoor Collinar coaxial antenna recorded for 18 hours with --gain 46, the tree line is much closer in this direction and long range performance is slightly worse.
More aircraft movements at the major airports are visible in this direction, though only by a small margin.
If you can see the horizon, you will be able to get 400+KM of range. The antenna is not tuned for 1090MHz but the ADS-B out is a very strong pulse. For a westward clear to the horizon window, I was able to get the following flights with a maximum range of 368.9770 km.
If you don't have a clear view of the horizon, see some antenna options below.
My first 1090MHz antenna was a wine cork dipole, then a more simplified version
with two copper wires soldered to the feed line. The wine cork worked reasonably but keeping the two
wires aligned vertically with alligator clips and tape was a challenge.
Using the dipole antenna soldered to the cable, high altitude flights (30000-45000 ft) come in to range at 50-70NM.
Recorded for approximately 2 days with --enable-agc (which set gain too 49.6). The tracking is much sparser than even 18 hours of the coax antenna.
There's a nice post on the flightaware forum titled Do I need a filter?. I tried it out with a few iterations of dongle and filter combinations.
Conclusion: Yes, I could use a filter and possibly one with a stronger bandpass slope.
$ rtl_power -f 800M:1200M:100k -i 30 -c 50% -e 30m -g 49 -F 9 > scan-faprostick-withfilt-r820t2.csv
Initial construction was with a simple 10 segment RG6 with a length of λ/2*VelocityFactor connected directly to a RG6 feed line.
This left the question, what do I do with the end segment? Leave it open, short it to the outside? I quickly found there are are many conflicting answers to this so that means more testing for me.
The relatively easy part is to calculate the wavelength. Divide the speed of light by the frequency, making sure to keep the units consistent (m/s and Hz). For ADS-B, our frequency is 1090MHz = 1.09*10^9.
λ=(c/ν)=299729458 (m/s) / 1090000000 (1/s)= 0.257 (m)
Additionaly, cables have a slower electromagnetic velocity than air so we have to compensate in our cable lengths. Cables with different dielectric insulators
will propogate the wave more slowly than others and common values
range betweeh 0.88c and 0.60c.
A reasonable guess is my RG6 coaxial cable has a velocity factor of approximately 0.85.
A bare wire will have a velocity factor of approximately 1, making a dipole calculation much easier.
Ferrite Beads, λ/4 element/wire on the end, ground planes, and conducting balun options all have design considerations.
rason.org suggests to add a λ/4 element to only the center conductor at the end. It also recommends another λ/4 conductor crimped where the feed line connects to the antenna with a ferrite coil at λ/2.
David suggests a 9th λ/4 element with a short to the outer conductor and a final λ/4 whip which end a quarter wavelength safter the 9th dielectric terminates.
An article from the radio experimenters handbook Suggests the original λ/2 assembly with ground plane elements. The two elements should be an X of two 3λ/4 elements approximately λ/3 down the feed line from the last antenna element.
nmearouter reminds us that the exposed λ/4 wire at the top should have a velocity factor of 1.
Finally ads-b.ca uses stripped LDF1-50 and uses the λ/4 9th segment shorted to the casing with a protruding λ/4 wire. A λ/4 sleeve balun before the feed line with no velocity factor adjustment completes the antenna.